The rubric
A score is not a vibe. Every app starts at five and moves on eight fixed axes.
What earns points
Each axis is scored 0–10 and weighted. Core job done without friction (25%), reliability over the fortnight (20%), value against the retail price (15%), data portability and export (10%), privacy defaults (10%), accessibility (10%), support response (5%), quality of onboarding (5%). The weighted result is rounded to one decimal.
What knocks an app down
A paywall that interrupts the core job, an account required before first use, an export that loses structure, ads in the paid tier, and any crash that costs logged data. Two of those and the ceiling is 7.0; four and it cannot pass 5.9.
The bands
| Band | Meaning |
|---|---|
| 9.0 – 10 | Front of the pack. We would install it again without hesitating. |
| 7.5 – 8.9 | Solid. Worth the install if you need this job done. |
| 6.0 – 7.4 | Workable with caveats. |
| Below 6.0 | Trail dust. Only if nothing else fits. |
How long we test
Fourteen days minimum per app, as the only tool for that job, on an iPhone 16, a Pixel 9 and a five-year-old laptop where the app has a web build. We pay the retail price in the same currency you will.
What we never do
Rank by affiliate commission, accept paid placement, quote vendor benchmarks as our own, or leave a con out because the app won. Where a category is close, we say so and give the deciding factor.
Questions about a score: letters@healthyhabitsforlifenj.com.